Amazon.com.au:Customer reviews: The Five: The Untold Lives of the Women Killed by Jack the Ripper

Top positive review

Famous Five Retold

Reviewed in Australia on 11 May 2020

I could not put this book down. It was recommended by the wonderful Dr Kat on YouTube. My Thesis at University touched on the edges of this subject so I was eager to read it.
I was not disappointed. At last a book which redresses the terrible imbalance in history of the “Ripper” crimes.
For some reason, I had never thought of the women involved as prostitutes, only destitute. Perhaps I had read between the lines even then, knowing that a paper only sells well with the most salacious of headlines.
If you are going to research the Whitechapel Murders, I suggest you START with this book, then move on to the others. Perhaps someone who starts with the innocent victims may see the crimes with new eyes.
Buy this book. It’s brilliant. It’s a glimpse into 1880s life of the poorest women in London, a London which was the centre of the British Empire, of vast wealth and wonder, prestige and power. And at its very tiny core, stinking, vile & rotten to the weakest of all.

Top critical review

All critical reviews›

Kindle Customer

Very insightful and well researched

Reviewed in Australia on 6 July 2020

A very thoroughly researched book that looks closely into the lives of the Ripper's unfortunate victims. I very much respect the effort that went into this as it can't have been easy and it pays a lot of respect to the women. Some bits were more interesting than others and at times maybe a bit overloaded with information and fancy words but a decent and different kind of read.

Sort by

Filter by

3,357 global ratings | 553 global reviews

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

From Australia

Famous Five Retold

Reviewed in Australia on 11 May 2020

Verified Purchase

Helpful

TJ Heap

This book is a revelation!

Reviewed in Australia on 21 April 2019

Verified Purchase

Many will think they know the truth of Jack the Ripper. Touted as the world’s first serial killer, he remains anonymous. “Jack” brutally murdered 5 prostitutes who were working the streets in one of the poorest areas of London in 1888. Despite the killer’s anonymity, or perhaps because of it, to date most of the dialogue on these murders has focused on the perpetrator - who was Jack, how did he do it, how did he escape capture, why did the killings stop? The killer has been celebritized, with books published, movies made, halloween costumes created, whilst his victims have been treated as mere footnotes. Barely worthy of remark. Treated as unworthy of interest as they were fallen women, prostitutes, so perhaps they even had it coming...

The Five challenges this standard narrative. It is not interested in who the killer was (a sick bastard to be sure!) - but who were the victims. Through meticulous research Hallie Rubenhold interweaves the lives of the five victims into our knowledge of Victorian society. The victims are alive in this book. Navigating their way through the trials and tribulations faced by the lower echelons of Victorian society. They were connected in life through their poverty. They are connected in death through the manner in which they were killed.

In this book each of the five victims, Polly, Annie, Elizabeth, Catherine and Mary Jane, are treated as somebody.

It was devastating to read their stories. To see their lives unraveling due, in many cases, to no fault of their own but by the simple lottery of who their parents were, and the fact that they were born female. Born into poverty their lives were an at times daily struggle. When often one misfortune lead to an unstoppable downwards spiral to destitution.

The misogynistic bias that has pervaded the ripper narrative is called out, challenged, and blown away by the sheer weight of evidence provided.

Reading their stories my heart broke in turn for Polly, Annie, Elizabeth, Kate and Mary Jane.

In attempting to address the bias, prejudice and inaccuracies of the Ripper narratives to date, this book goes an important step further - it gives the five back their dignity. These were five women. Living their lives as best they could. There lives mercilessly cut short in horrific manner.

It is time to stop glorifying and celebritizing the killer and remember the victims for what they were. People. Each one was somebody. Included photographs of victims and associates in life a poignant reminder of this truth. The lists of items recovered on their bodies offers a real glimpse into who these women were, how they lived and what they held to be dear and important.

This book is terrific. A lone, but strong and defining voice in the Ripper narratives. Attempting to rebalance the injustices done to these women from the time their lives were brutally taken from them.

A must read!

2 people found this helpful

Helpful

Matthew Barker

Incredibly well researched!

Reviewed in Australia on 28 March 2019

Verified Purchase

This is a phenomenal achievement of research. It brings to life the diverse, multilayered and complex lives of five women whom history has sadly turned into two dimensional caricatures. This book is a real achievement. More than 130 years after Jack the Ripper murdered Annie, Mary Ann, Polly, Elizabeth, and Mary Jane, there is much to learn still that applies in a modern society.

Helpful

Kindle Customer

Very insightful and well researched

Reviewed in Australia on 6 July 2020

Reviewed in Australia on 3 March 2019

Verified Purchase

If I wanted a book on the social history of victorian slums this would be it. Slogged through the first part and then gave up after poor old Polly. It just waffled on with facts and figures with the five just popped in amongst it. Skipped to the end. Not much better. Best part was the photographs.

One person found this helpful

Helpful

mezzo

Historical look at women in that period.

Reviewed in Australia on 4 September 2020

Verified Purchase

This was a very interesting book and very well written. I especially liked the fact that it didn't touch on the life of Jack the Ripper himself as that would have turned it into a fiction and it was good to just read the true story of the five victims.

Helpful

Ilovereading

The story of the women murdered by Jack the Ripper

Reviewed in Australia on 25 July 2019

Verified Purchase

Interesting historical perspective of the Jack the Ripper story. What I particularly liked is that this was the story of five women and JtR is hardly mentioned.

One person found this helpful

Helpful