Best Rated in Eye Makeup

Compare the most helpful customer reviews of the best rated products in our Eye Makeup shop. These products are shortlisted based on the overall star rating and the number of customer reviews received by each product in the shop, and are refreshed regularly.

Top rated products in Eye Makeup

1 offer from product price
4.4 | 5,780 customer ratings
86% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
One of the best eyeliners I've we found. Easy to apply and comes with as spooly
        Read more
By Alison Haines
Love it's the wind up type
        Read more
By K123456789
Love it. Love it
        Read more
By Jan Hall
4.4 | 5,159 customer ratings
84% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Love it, my favourite doesn’t clump
        Read more
By Jacquie
Best mascara I have used. Makes my eye lashes look much thicker and longer
        Read more
By Cheryl
Perfect consistency for eyelashes
        Read more
By Charlie420
4.4 | 4,081 customer ratings
85% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Bought for my daughter and daughter in law and they had been looking at this product and it will make getting ready for work a lot shorter.
        Read more
By Susan Scott
I didn't expect it to work as well as it did - but it worked really well!! So much easier than drawing a cat's eye by hand! Nice and dark as well.
        Read more
By Dovie
What good is it's waterproof but the stencil end it's not professionally accomplished as it's advertising. Delivery to my destination and to me was quick and there were no signs of damage. Thank you
        Read more
By Lalita Singh
1 offer from product price
4.4 | 1,511 customer ratings
85% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Perfect
        Read more
By Anji
It is a great product at a very reasonable price. Easy to apply and just the subtle kind of color i wanted.
I have darkest brown color and it just blends beautifully.
        Read more
By Happy Customer
Great product should have bought more than just the two. I use them everyday as I have no eyebrows thanks to over plucking when young.
        Read more
By Carol
4.4 | 818 customer ratings
86% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
ease of application, inexpensive, always at finger tips when eyebrows need a touch up
        Read more
By Rhonda Anderson
Ive only used it once but it took easily. And seems to be holding.
        Read more
By ER
I bought this product thinking this was all I needed, after waiting weeks for it to arrive I discovered that I also needed the activation solution which would take another 4 weeks to arrive. This wasn't stated anywhere when I purchased the product. I bought a kit from my local supermarket that did the same thing and was a lot more accessib
        Read more
By Megan Letts
4.3 | 2,283 customer ratings
81% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
This mascara is a pleasure to apply and gives unreal results! Longer thicker lashes. Wipes the floor with more expensive brands...believe me Ive tried them all!
        Read more
By alibearoz
Brought this after seeing a review by an instagram influencer. This works better than other more expensive Mascara. This doesn’t run or flake. It also make my lash looks longer.
        Read more
By NToh
This seems to be the waterproof version (although it doesn’t say that anywhere), since it doesn’t come off easily like the regular one. I’ve been buying this mascara for a few years now, and love it, but this is different and not for me. As a waterproof mascara, I’d say it’s brilliant, it hasn’t been dry clumpy or flaky for me.
        Read more
By Nina
1 offer from product price
4.3 | 1,986 customer ratings
82% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Provides a gentle, natural enhancement to your eyelashes and extends their length. Soft and not clumpy, easy to remove. Not a mascara if you're needing "thicker" lashes.
        Read more
By Paula
Excellent Mascara doesn't feel heavy on lashes and doesn't irritate my eyes, lovely to use.
        Read more
By Pruedence Corr
Is a bit clumpy but if applied right is a good mascara & easy to remove with water
        Read more
By Arnu
4.3 | 928 customer ratings
81% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Used this for my scene look, I found it harder to use than a pencil liner but it's definitely good
        Read more
By WB
I would recommend
        Read more
By Chloe Wilson
Great product,easy to apply.Will order again.
        Read more
By Usha
1 offer from product price
4.5 | 256 customer ratings
86% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I absolutely love this product and have been using it for months, this is the first time I’ve bought it in this shade though. Great for blonde or light brown hair, this pomade lasts ALL day, even on my fairly oily skin.
100% recommend, seller was fast to ship out product, with no issues
        Read more
By frogbutton
The pomade is easy to apply with the brush and keeps the brow hairs in shape. Stays all day.
        Read more
By Aries53
Great product stays on all day and night and easy to use
        Read more
By Yasmin
2 offers from product price
4.2 | 2,938 customer ratings
78% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I love buying these, truly one of the best eyeliners around and reasonably priced too
        Read more
By V
Fantastic color, easy to apply, really thin tip for precise application.
        Read more
By Louise
I liked it. The brush is perfect to apply a thin or thick liner
        Read more
By Padmavati
1 offer from product price
4.4 | 361 customer ratings
85% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
By danistar930
More than you need. Very good value.
        Read more
By S.DL
Quality of the product is not good.
        Read more
By Divya
4.3 | 630 customer ratings
83% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Rimmel make up is always good stuff
        Read more
By Janene Tessari
Good smooth makeup
        Read more
By Steph Silver
Does the job but still smudges under my eye eventuallyas with every other eyeliner I buy. I was hoping it would be the one to stay. Formula is very nice, creamy and great colour payoff. No dragging
        Read more
By Lucy
1 offer from product price
4.3 | 622 customer ratings
81% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I always love Rimmel make up
        Read more
By Janene Tessari
Really nice colour
        Read more
By Janene Tessari
Waterproof Nice colour
        Read more
By PIA
4.4 | 345 customer ratings
84% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
This is a really nice mascara. Not sure about the falsies push up, but the mascara works like any good mascara, and washes off very easily with water
        Read more
By Happy
There is no product seen when you take the wand out. But don't get fooled, it applies with no clumps and the wand curls the lashes at the same time!
        Read more
By Anjali Jain
I like the curved brush and it doesn't clump
        Read more
By WB
4.2 | 1,440 customer ratings
79% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
My eyes react badly to eyeliner and kohl usually - I have no such allergy problems with this product.
It is also soft so goes on smoothly and can be deliberately smudged, but then 'dries' so I don't end the day looking like a panda bear.
My eyelids are 70yo, so a smooth finish is no mean feat. 😊
        Read more
By Trish Kroll
Great for those who still love the pencil eye!
        Read more
By S.C.
Great product
        Read more
By tammy horn
4.6 | 98 customer ratings
87% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Really easy to apply. You don’t hve to worry about a super straight perfect line as the lashes are put on top so you don’t see it. Really impressive
        Read more
By DEBORAH J COLLINS
It does what it claims and the eyeliner is unexpectedly good.
        Read more
By Nina
The lashes themselves are not the best quality, however, they are amazingly easy to put on and they will stay on all day. Great for someone who finds gluing eyelashes on hard. Really recommend.
        Read more
By Gillian Cooper
1 offer from product price
4.5 | 105 customer ratings
82% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Its easy to use. I dont use the stencils as they are different to my eyebrow shape. I use a slanted eye brush and I get great looking brows.
        Read more
By Yvonne Wilkins
I used this product before, happy with my purchase.
        Read more
By Miriam Guerrero
I bought them for my granddaughter
        Read more
By Jacqueline Lovett
4.2 | 228 customer ratings
78% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Maybelline products especially mascaras are great for eyes. I hate to see 'clumping' and lashes joined together - you can put a light coat on first and them add volume my reapplying. I love their products.
        Read more
By helen mature age Aussie
Great product
        Read more
By tammy horn
Good value
        Read more
By Suz
2 offers from product price
4.6 | 76 customer ratings
90% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Good Colour selection, different than their others, not much double up which is good, nice pigmentation.
        Read more
By Tania Ford
It’s perfect for value and I love Maybelline products . Amazon is super fast and this is a great deal
        Read more
By ris
Very good colour set. Prompt delivery.
        Read more
By Pallavi B
1 offer from product price
4.2 | 67 customer ratings
79% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Works really well! I haven't really used eye primer before but it has made a huge difference to my make up routine. I don't get panda eyes by the end of the day from my eyeshadow and eyeliner. I kind of lazily apply it with the wand and rub it over my eyelids. Works really well for lashes under mascara too. I was also surprised at how my f
        Read more
By Rachel
Great goes on easy
        Read more
By julie ann
My eye makeup now stays in after using this primer.At times it is a little too dry which means applying eye shadow can be tricky.Still manageable though.
        Read more
By Erika E Gray