Top rated in Eye Makeup

Compare the most helpful customer reviews of the best rated products in our Eye Makeup shop. These products are shortlisted based on the overall star rating and the number of customer reviews received by each product in the shop, and are refreshed regularly.

Top rated products in Eye Makeup

product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.6 | 17,606 customer ratings
88% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Great
        Read more
By Em
Great colours great
        Read more
By Amazon Customer
I use it for my cosplays all the
        Read more
By Toko
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.6 | 7,793 customer ratings
91% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I've tried so many different eyebrow products and this is one of the few that has a really good colour - not that weird orange undertone. So easy to apply, easy to sharpen with a small twist and surprisingly has lasted a few months - albeit I just fill in
        Read more
By Em H
It's usually so hard to find a good colour match with a drugstore eyeliner that doesn't pull too warm. This colour is perfect for me. The tip is fine, and you can really create a nice brow with it. You can keep it light and natural, or create a more defined brown. What a great find. My other eyebrow product is around $50 and I definitely
        Read more
By Madison Ouston
Applies easily, achieving fine hair-like lines. The colour is true with no greenish tinge that I can detect.I apply the colour Soft Brown with the Blonde for a more natural effect. Looks really
        Read more
By Kitty
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.6 | 3,664 customer ratings
92% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I absolutely love this product and have been using it for months, this is the first time I’ve bought it in this shade though. Great for blonde or light brown hair, this pomade lasts ALL day, even on my fairly oily skin.100% recommend, seller was fast to ship out product, with no
        Read more
By frogbutton
The pomade is easy to apply with the brush and keeps the brow hairs in shape. Stays all
        Read more
By Aries53
Item is easy to apply and is long
        Read more
By Ron Baines
4.5 | 53,360 customer ratings
86% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
i’ve been using this on my brows & lashes and OMG i’ve noticed results not even 3 days in!! this product is absolutely
        Read more
By Cece
It actually works! I am buying more
        Read more
By Charlie
This oil is very
        Read more
By Biddy11
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.5 | 34,618 customer ratings
87% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Love it, my favourite doesn’t
        Read more
By Jacquie
The actual result is 5 stars but Maybelline is not cruelty free, which I wish I’d known before purchasing this mascara. I’m very impressed with how it applies, lengthens and adds volume to my lashes but steer clear if you don’t want to support animal testing. Another website recommended Wet n Wild mascara as an alternative which I
        Read more
By Erica Beattie
Didn't give the results I
        Read more
By saad s.
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.5 | 13,952 customer ratings
86% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I have never been great with liquid liner but this makes the application so easy! Love love
        Read more
By Deb
I love it, easy to use and last
        Read more
By TRANG NGUYEN
Really good works
        Read more
By Vicky
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.6 | 2,655 customer ratings
88% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
ease of application, inexpensive, always at finger tips when eyebrows need a touch
        Read more
By Rhonda Anderson
Ive only used it once but it took easily. And seems to be
        Read more
By ER
I bought this product thinking this was all I needed, after waiting weeks for it to arrive I discovered that I also needed the activation solution which would take another 4 weeks to arrive. This wasn't stated anywhere when I purchased the product. I bought a kit from my local supermarket that did the same thing and was a lot more
        Read more
By Megan Letts
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.5 | 5,353 customer ratings
87% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I have used other products which I feel are better than the one I have purchased.I have started using it and will not return it for a refund.I am satisfied but will not buy it again as better products are available in the market for the same
        Read more
By Pratibha Gokani
Very good quality! Does a good job fluffing and filling in brows and looks very clean and
        Read more
By Sari
it's
        Read more
By Samaher
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.4 | 9,870 customer ratings
83% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Excellent product easy to apply. Very good
        Read more
By Harold
This mascara help seperate my lashes but not that
        Read more
By kusam
Like.a cheaper brand nothing speacial the purple falsies are way
        Read more
By Ezo
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.4 | 6,894 customer ratings
83% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Happy with the quality, worth the price as I bought when was on special first time using it and so happy 2ith
        Read more
By SHAHRAM
Blends in well, great
        Read more
By V
Initially I tried this a few times underneath the Maybelline Lash Sensational Waterproof, created really good volume. However, due to it (I assume not being waterproof) and I have watery eyes, pretty much 60% of the mascara came off. It flaked all over my cheeks and there was barely any mascara left. For that reason I find this pretty
        Read more
By Naomi
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.4 | 2,850 customer ratings
84% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Easy to apply. Lasts for ages. No creasing or flaking. Really lovely colours. Have 2 shades and intending to add more
        Read more
By simone mighall
I have several of these eyeshadow creams. This is not an everyday colour but definitely
        Read more
By Jayne
It didn't go on
        Read more
By LAB
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.3 | 23,309 customer ratings
80% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I haven’t used an eyeshadow pencil since I was a teen but I’m loving the ease of application and the ability to be very precise. You can even line your eye with this product for a different
        Read more
By Aggie
It is a beautiful pencil easy to use.My friends are commenting on if I have got my brows professionally
        Read more
By Pratibha Gokani
It works. Did me well for my halloween costume. The issue is that it doesn't extend. You're meant to use a sharpener like a makeup pencil. But you only get the tip. There is no turn dial to extend to get more. So you get very
        Read more
By Timothy
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.3 | 19,645 customer ratings
80% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
The stopper in the tube removes all the product to the point where the brush is DRY.Remove the stopper and control the amount of product
        Read more
By Aisha
Loved the consistency, I can definitely feel like it gelled my eyebrows well and also defined my hairs, wish the brush was a little smaller but it still worked
        Read more
By Vera
Bought for my teen. Smells like chemicals… not super effective. It’s ok in a pinch but I wouldn’t repurchase. Made in
        Read more
By Aggie
4.4 | 1,840 customer ratings
85% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
This company is so amazing. There Products are such good quality as they are so cheap and the packaging is amazing ! Will 100% be buying from this lovely company
        Read more
By Ella
Good quality. alue for
        Read more
By Graham Pace
I don't know what I hate more tweezers that cut or tweezers that don't grab! Amzingly these do both they're almost like scissors - they pretty much cut the hair the moment they get a grip on it - no pulling required. See videothey also brown stuff on the blade which I'm guessing is either rust or blood - pre used?? 🤮 see
        Read more
By Amazon Customer
4.3 | 4,286 customer ratings
79% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
By nikita
Came in perfect condition and faster than expected. Overall good product
        Read more
By chicken
Dry mascara. waste of
        Read more
By glynis tudor
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.3 | 2,616 customer ratings
82% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
It is a great every day
        Read more
By Dana Kiley
Only used it once so far, nice slim brush and no clumpy, so far so
        Read more
By rubyred
It seemed dried up , I put the brush inside & no product comes
        Read more
By natasha zharofsky
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.2 | 7,505 customer ratings
82% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I love buying these, truly one of the best eyeliners around and reasonably priced
        Read more
By V
I liked it. The brush is perfect to apply a thin or thick
        Read more
By Padmavati
By Lana
4.2 | 1,873 customer ratings
77% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I usually buy a pair of the Ardell Wispies for $10, as they are my faaavv. And I thought I'd buy this brand just to trail. And honestly, they're the same as the Ardell ones!! But I get 5 pairs of great quality lashes for the same price instead of one. These are now my new
        Read more
By Be Pozachi
I am very satisfied with the product. It is cheap but very good quality. The lash band is thin and the lashes are very natural. If you want more of a fluffier look, stack them! They wont feel heavy! They only look
        Read more
By Zean
I like those but I would love more if they have the set with all of them. I got the classic ones but I think it comes with a lot of the same. Which is good for people that use every day or work with that. But for me I would rather if it comes with different kind of lashes but overall they are good and easy to
        Read more
By ana carla
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.1 | 11,269 customer ratings
73% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Even though I’m a beauty therapist and have done henna many times, it’s always nerve racking using a new product but I highly recommend this! My brows came out the perfect shade after 15minutes.Little tips: make sure you mix it’s really well and make sure you exfoliate your eye brows before applying so you get an even
        Read more
By Sky
Easy to use and great value. I have blonde eyebrows and was spending $40 everytime I went to the salon every few weeks. This is amazing and does the same job! I reapply every 10 days as I have gaps in my eyebrows so like the filled in look the henna gives me. I would say this pack will last me 4 months so very cost effective too. Overall
        Read more
By louise
How utterly dangerous and irresponsible of the seller to not list PPD in the ingredients. I wasted my money trusting the listing info, and thinking this was a PPD-free product. What's worse is that the pamphlet ENCOURAGES you to put this on your eyelashes in your eye! Do the right things and be
        Read more
By Ellie
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.4 | 565 customer ratings
83% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Maybelline products especially mascaras are great for eyes. I hate to see 'clumping' and lashes joined together - you can put a light coat on first and them add volume my reapplying. I love their
        Read more
By helen mature age Aussie
By tammy horn
I find sussing out the best Mascara quite difficult these days. They all claim to make your eye lashes look Colossal, Volumized and miles long. This one is just ordinary in my opinion. It was cheap so I am not complaining but had I paid full price, I would not have been happy. Had to put some 'eye drops' in it, it was so thick and
        Read more
By Heather Tailor