On the plus side, this tent is lightweight and easy to set up. It could fit 3 people side by side with no room for gear inside the tent, or 2 people and their gear (which is how I had it) quite comfortably. I think I might have just gotten a dud as there are so many good reviews and I also purchased the green 2 person version of this tent and it has performed spectacularly.
We took the 2 person green one out on that trip, and then another trip a few days ago where we had a very stormy night with thunder, pouring rain and wind, and the little green tent had no issues whatsoever and remained perfectly dry inside.
If this tent didn't leak, it would have gotten 5 stars as it would be a good tent if it didn't leak. Like I said, I think I may have just gotten a dud.