Joe Lapp was a doctor in an English town, but his heart was still Amish, and he still visited his family twice every month. When Mary did not arrive home while he was visiting her house, he set out to find her, and he never wanted to leave her side even after she was discharged from hospital and his care.
Months later, it was evident that Mary would have to forever live with the repercussion of that night. Could a single mother be accepted in the strict confines of the Amish community? Would Joe suffer for his love of the mother and her child? Can an innocent woman, the man who loves her and a faithful Amish family live a normal life after such an unimaginable tragedy?